By

Benjamin Yamb

University of Douala, Cameroon

Oscar Bayemi

University of Douala, Cameroon

University of Bedfordshire, United Kingdom

e-ISBN: 978-605-7736-63-5
Publishing Date: December 15, 2019
File Size: 3,940 MB ‎
Length: xv + 131 pages (PDF)
Language: ‎ English
Dimensions: ‎13,5 x 21,5 cm

This Book is completely open access. You can freely read, download and share with everyone.
(Ch.1) This Chapter analyzes and highlights the most practised forms of corruption in public hospitals of Douala metropolis in Cameroon, namely corruption with theft and that without theft. The results of our analyzes show a predominance of the form without theft, this regardless of the hospital, and this allowed us to classify hospitals based on the dominant form. It appears that the General and Deido Hospitals are health facilities where corruption without theft is the least and the most practiced respectively, while the Cité des Palmiers and New Bell hospitals are those where corruption with theft is the least and the most practiced. An estimate through odds ratios revealed for instance that the odds would be about 5.46 times higher that the form without theft is not practiced at the General hospital compared to other hospitals, and about 11.11 times that it is practiced at Deido hospital compared to all hospitalsh.
(Ch.2) The problem that arises is how the State official in a monopoly situation maximizes the value of bribes collected, by selling public services to users? To answer this question, we show that the State agent in a monopoly situation can discriminate users according to their characteristics in order to collect more possible bribes. The Shleifer and Vishny’ simple monopoly model is therefore limited. The survey of patients of nine public hospitals in Douala revealed the existence of two forms of corruption at consultation: corruption without theft and corruption with theft. An evaluation of maximizing the earnings of medical doctors using odds ratios, showed that in the pursuit of these gains and whatever the form of corruption practiced, the State agent plays not only on amounts of bribes paid, but also on users’ characteristics. However, for amounts between 3,000 FCFA and 5,000 FCFA, our results revealed that the doctor will tend to practice the form of corruption without theft on men, the wealthiest, the learned and the old where he/she would draw the greatest possible gain.
(Ch.3) The problem that arises is how the State official in a monopoly situation maximizes the value of bribes collected, by selling public services to users? To answer this question, we show first that in the case of health care provision, the Shleifer and Vishny’ simple monopoly model which highlights two forms of corruption (with theft and without theft) is limited insofar as it underestimates not only the value of bribes likely to be collected, but also the loss of income that corrupt practices cause to public services. Our model rather reveals that the State agent in a monopoly situation can discriminate users according to their characteristics in order to collect more possible bribes. Indeed, our model shows that when a medical doctor maximizes its earnings and whatever the form of corruption practiced, he plays not only on amounts of bribes paid and a part of the official price, but also on users’ characteristics. However, for some amounts the State agent will tend to practice the form of corruption without theft on certain users’ characteristics where he/she would draw the greatest possible gain.
(Ch.4) This chapter deeply analyzes the characteristics of corrupters during consultation in the Douala public hospitals, as well as the amounts of bribe they pay. A survey of patients in these hospitals reveals that the majority of bribes paid during consultation is between 1,000 and 3,000 CFA Francs, interval which corresponds to the 25th and 75th percentile of the amounts of bribe paid respectively. Our estimates indicate that for the amounts of bribe paid falling within this interval, it appears that the rich, the women, the older and the more educated are more likely to corrupt practices. However, when such amounts are set outside of that interval, the amounts of bribe paid and the characteristics of corrupters are no more the same as before. This contradicts for instance to some extent some theoretical results that do not include the setting of the level of bribe. It finally emerges from our analysis that with regard to each of the characteristics highlighted, correspond specific amounts of bribe paid, which are related to the socio-professional and socio-demographic categories of patients. In particular, senior staffs and business men / contractors would be most likely to pay bribes, whatever the amount.
(Ch.5) This chapter studies the characteristics of victims of corruption in the different public hospitals of the city of Douala in Cameroon. A survey of 407 frequent users of at least one of these hospitals allowed us to identify, using corruption indexes, the services mostly affected such as hospitalization, reception, medical certificate, illicit sales of drugs and hospitals in which they are located. Estimates obtained through odd ratios showed that the characteristics of victims vary not only from one hospital to another, but also from one service to another. For example, in the case of hospitalization, the victims are in general of male sex, aged 40 or below, and earners of incomes above 250,000F CFA, meanwhile in the case of illicit sales of drugs, men as well as women with incomes less than 250,000F CFA are affected. This allowed us to classify hospitals in terms of the magnitude of the phenomenon in the various services.
(Ch.6) This chapter highlights the initiative taken for the corrupt habits of health services suppliers and users of healthcare in Cameroon. An analysis through proportions reveals that generally in the regions, 83.33% of health workers take the initiative for the corruption, mainly justified by the prominence of some motives such as the deficit of nursing staff and drugs, the inadequate infrastructure and medical equipments, and the difficulties encountered in the implementation of the budget. An analysis through odds ratios for the entire country and by region revealed that in the health care market, the initiative for the corrupt act usually comes from the medical personnel in about 58% of cases, compared to the paramedical staff (33%). In 9% of cases, there is no conclusion between the first and the second. The use of a log-linear model through the Poisson regression enabled us to highlight the characteristics of patients in regions where the corrupt act is initiated by them. Indeed, the women, the younger and the workers are most prone to corrupt actions. However, the residential environment (urban or rural) does not influence the corrupt practices.
Preface
 
Chapter I
Corruption forms and health care provision in Douala metropolis public hospitals of Cameroon
Introduction
Literature review
Methodological acpects
The basic model; Determination and characteristics of the sample size; Estimation methodology: An approach through odds ratios.
Hospitals’ functioning and corrupt practices
Findings and discussion
Descriptive statistics and estimate through odds ratios; Discussion.
Conclusion
References
 
Chapter II
Corruption and discrimination in Douala metropolis public hospitals of Cameroon
Introduction
The Methodological aspects of the model evaluation
Hospitals’ functioning and corrupt pratices
Results and discussion
Determination and characteristics of the sample’s size; Amounts of bribe paid during consultation; Characteristics of victims through discrimination.
Conclusion
References
 
Chapter III
Corruption and health care provision: An extension of the Shleifer and Vishny’ Model
Introduction
Basic theoretical model
Discussion of the model
Conclusion and recommendations
References
 
Chapter IV
Bribery in Cameroonian public hospitals: Who pays and how much?
Introduction
Health, Health Care and Corruption in Cameroonian Hospitals
Health and health care; Corruption in health services.
Methodology and Descriptive Statistics
Determining the sample; Some descriptive statistics.
Statistical Estimate of Patients’ Characteristics Victims of the Phenomenon
Discussion
Conclusion
Appendix
References
 
Chapter V
An empirical evaluation of the characteristics of the victims of corruption in public hospitals in Cameroon: The case of Douala metropolis
Introduction
Hospitals and their functioning in the city of Douala
Materials and method
Determining the sample’s size and its characteristics; Calculating corruption indexes; Statistical estimate and characteristics of victims: An approach by odds ratios.
Manifestation of corruption and indexes’ calculation
Corruption indexes; Manifestations of corruption in services.
Results and discussion
Presentation of results; The comparison of victims’ profiles from one hospital to another concerning the same service.
Conclusion and recommendations
Appendix
References
 
Chapter VI
Corruption and health services market in Cameroon: Who takes the initiative?
Introduction
Literature review
Motives and practices of initiative taking
Corrupt practices observed and actors’ behavior; Motives for initiative taking: Shortage in service supply.
Materials and method
Results and discussion
Initiative taken by Providers; Initiative taken by patients.
Conclusion and recommendations

References 

Benjamin Yamb

Benjamin Yamb is professor of economics and statistics at the Advanced School of Economics and Commerce at the University of Douala in Cameroon. He was Head of International Trade and Management Department for almost 10 years (2003-2013) where he set up the professional master degree in International Trade and Supply Chain Management. He holds a Master degree in Economics (University of Montreal, Quebec Canada), a master degree in Statistics (The American University Washington DC) and a doctorate in economics (University of Paris 1 pantheon Sorbonne). He is the author of several publications in local and international journals. He has served as a consultant in many international organizations, such as the European Union where he set up a system for collecting, processing and analyzing commercial data in Chad. His areas of interest are financial macroeconomics including exchange rates, governance models in this case in developing countries and discrete choice statistical models.

Oscar Bayemi

Doctor accredited to supervise research studies in economic sciences, Oscar Victor Bayemi is the Vice Dean of Reseach and Cooperation at the Faculty of Economics and Applied Management of the University of Douala, Cameroon. Married and father of many childreen , his is the consultant in the economic problems of devevoping countries such as corruption. He has also published many articles in scientific journals.

Related EconPedia Items

Upcoming Books